fbpx
Sunday, September 27th, 2020
Home » The Human Element » Sweden was stupid to ignore social distancing. Now thousands are going to die

Sweden was stupid to ignore social distancing. Now thousands are going to die

People in Stockholm work out and share outdoor gym equipment and ignore social distancing advice from the authorities

BLOOMBERG, APRIL 4, 2020

Sweden’s death rate per capita is 4 times that of its neighbor Norway where a tougher coronavirus lockdown is in place. Sweden has largely ignored common sense, proven measures to reduce the transmission of the virus. Thousands of Swedes are going to die as a result.

By Niclas Rolander and Charles Daly – There are signs that the death rate in Sweden is growing faster than elsewhere in Scandinavia, raising pressure on the government to abandon its controversial hands-off approach in tackling Covid-19.

The Swedish experiment has drawn international bewilderment as schools, restaurants and cafes have remained open. And while other countries passed laws restricting movement, Sweden’s Prime Minister Stefan Lofven relied on the common sense of his fellow citizens to carry his country through the pandemic.

SWEDEN-HEALTH-VIRUS-PRESSER
Sweden’s Prime Minister Stefan Lofven Photographer: Jonathan Nackstrand/AFP via Getty Images

But after a week of sobering data, Lofven now seems to be striking a darker tone. In an interview published on Saturday by Dagens Nyheter, he warned that Sweden may be facing “thousands” of coronavirus deaths, and said the crisis is likely to drag on for months rather than weeks. Meanwhile, newspaper Expressen reported that his Social Democrat-led government may be seeking extraordinary powers to bypass parliament and force through a sterner response to the virus.

People walk along the main pedestrian shopping street in Stockholm ignoring social distancing common sense rules
People walk along the main pedestrian shopping street in Stockholm ignoring social distancing common-sense rules, March 25, 2020. (Photo/David Keyton)

The number of Swedish deaths rose to 373 on Saturday, up 12% from Friday. That brings the rate per million in Scandinavia’s biggest economy to 36, compared with 29 in Denmark and 9 in Norway, where much tougher lockdowns are in place.

Sweden’s top epidemiologist, Anders Tegnell, says the goal in his country, like everywhere else, is to “flatten the curve” to avoid overwhelming hospitals. As of Thursday, he said that curve is “starting to become somewhat steeper, but overall” remains “fairly flat.”

Sweden’s death rate per capita is 4 times that of its neighbor Norway where tougher coronavirus lockdown are in place

But Covid-19 comes with so many unknowns that Sweden’s approach has some of its own experts worried.

“They are used to making evidence-based decisions, but that doesn’t work for a pandemic like this, where key coordinates are unknown,” said Claudia Hanson, a Stockholm-based senior lecturer in global public health.

The history of social isolation as an intelligent response to outbreaks like Covid-19 is compelling. Roughly a century ago, when the world was dealing with the Spanish flu, two U.S. cities ended up becoming case studies due to their very different approaches. In Philadelphia, the city staged a parade with 200,000 people a week and a half after the first case was identified, and quickly saw a sharp spike in the death rate. In St. Louis, officials imposed tough social distancing rules; the death rate there was less than half Philadelphia’s.

Meanwhile, the economic cost of shutting down an entire society has added another layer to the debate. But with much of the rest of the world going into lockdown, Sweden’s efforts to keep its economy open aren’t doing much to shield it from recession. In fact, some economists warn Swedish GDP may contract as much as 8% this year, which would represent a far deeper crisis than in 2008-2009.

Sweden has already taken a few steps toward more restrictions. It recently banned gatherings larger than 50, compared with 500 previously. And restaurants can only serve patrons while they’re seated at tables, not while standing at bars. Visits to retirement homes for the elderly are banned, and Lofven has made clear stricter instructions may follow.

But it remains a far cry from measures taken elsewhere. In neighboring Denmark, citizens face hefty fines and even prison sentences for breaking new coronavirus laws. Controversially, the government has also made it easier to expel immigrants as part of the freshly minted legislation.

Lofven has so far sought to play down the role of legislation in shaping Sweden’s response.

“We will never be able to legislate everything, we will never be able to ban all harmful actions,” Lofven said last week. “We all as individuals must take our responsibility.”

— With assistance by Mikael Holter

Other articles you may find interesting

Copyright © 2020 PortandTerminal.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, written or redistributed.

Check Also

Aerial view of clouds with glow of fires below.

Maritime of the Day: “Fire Through the Clouds”

PortandTerminal.com, September 26, 2020 HALIFAX, NOVA SCOTIA – Today’s “Maritime Image of the Day” appeared …

Man rescuing dog at sea

Leaked Video: Lost dog seen swimming in the sea rescued by passing ferry passenger

PortandTerminal.com, September 25, 2020 HALIFAX, NOVA SCOTIA – In times like these, a feel-good story …